In Episode 36 of America First Gen X, Jackson Steele lays out what he describes as four reasons America First conservatives should break with MAGA in the midterm elections and begin preparing for a new political movement heading toward 2028.Jackson opens by criticizing voters who rely on partisan media or campaign messaging without researching competing arguments. He distinguishes between people he believes are simply uninformed and political operatives who, in his view, knowingly promote misleading narratives for money, influence, or party loyalty.A central theme is what Jackson calls the “battered conservative” problem.He argues that Republican leaders repeatedly campaign on reducing government, enforcing immigration law, protecting constitutional rights, and opposing foreign intervention—only to abandon those promises once in power. Jackson says conservatives are then told they must continue supporting Republicans because the Democratic alternative would be worse.His first argument is that MAGA must face political consequences.Jackson believes the movement has abandoned the original America First coalition by embracing neoconservative foreign policy, expanded federal authority, and strong alignment with Israel.
He points to opposition to Representative Thomas Massie as an example of the growing divide between MAGA leadership and anti-interventionist conservatives.The second argument centers on divided government.Jackson rejects predictions that Democratic control of Congress would automatically produce catastrophe. Instead, he argues that a Democratic-controlled House and Senate combined with a Republican executive branch could create gridlock and prevent either party from exercising unchecked power.For Jackson, that is a feature rather than a flaw.He says he distrusts concentrated political power regardless of which party controls Washington and argues that constitutional government works best when competing branches and parties restrain one another.The third part of the episode focuses on AIPAC and political influence.Jackson argues that voters should pay greater attention to campaign funding, lobbying relationships, and foreign-policy organizations when evaluating candidates. He wants support from AIPAC and other strongly pro-Israel political organizations to receive the same scrutiny as any other major source of political influence.Jackson presents the midterms as a potential referendum on what he calls “Israel First” politics within the Republican Party.
He argues that candidates should be judged according to whether they place American constitutional and national interests ahead of commitments to any foreign government.The fourth argument is about creating space for a third party.Jackson believes a major MAGA defeat could weaken party control over conservatives who currently fear political retaliation for challenging Donald Trump or Republican leadership. In his view, that could create an opening for libertarians, traditional Catholics, conservative Democrats, constitutional conservatives, independents, and antiwar voters to form a broader America First coalition.He warns, however, that not every independent movement represents genuine reform. Jackson again criticizes former Senator Joe Manchin, whom he sees as part of the political establishment rather than an authentic third-party alternative.The episode also discusses Pennsylvania Senators John Fetterman and Dave McCormick.
Jackson argues that their cooperation on Israel illustrates a form of bipartisanship based primarily on foreign policy rather than broader ideological agreement.Subscribe to America First Gen X for ongoing conversations about constitutional government, political accountability, foreign policy, civil liberties, national sovereignty, and the future of the America First movement.Topics Covered:
Adapted in layout from the publisher’s episode description. Political arguments and opinions in these notes are attributed to the host.
Open this episode on Spotify